Don’t bother improving your chess

Civil discourse requires a shared allegiance to civil society โ€œIf every time you play chess, your opponent punches you in the face, getting better at chess is not the solution.โ€ โ€“ Andrew Thomas An important life lesson came out of my early career as a civil litigator. I practiced law in Canada for eleven years; …

“After me, the flood:” recovering the Army’s accountability

Much has been written elsewhere regarding theย unforgivable sinย ofย failing to planย forย known contingencies. Whatever one thinks of the current changes undergoing our Army here in the United States, the least controversial thing to be said about them is that they certainly represent a change from what has come before. And regardless of one what thinks, orย refuses to …

What are the Obligations of Leadership?

I was in Hawaii for the first time earlier this year. Expecting a sunny beach vacation, it was actually more of a profound learning experience. I was not expecting to be provoked in thought as much as I was. For our purposes, the thing that stayed with me most was the state motto, formerly the …

Failure Mechanisms in Democratic Regimes โ€“ an Armyโ€™s Role

The United States was born of a desire to leave behind monarchial government and instead live under a republic. Although the structure of the United States was explicitly crafted to have both democratic and anti-democratic elements, the perils of democracy have been part of the American discussion from the beginning (โ€œWhen a majority is included in a faction, …

The Dynamics of Regime-Supporting Irregular Paramilitary Forcesย 

(pro-government militias) While most regimes and governments rely on traditional bases of power - democratic legitimacy, hereditary monarchy, etc. - all rely to some extent on the potential for violence to keep their authority intact. Regimes employ a variety of military and police forces for external defense and internal order/repression. In some countries these various …

Water is Wet: “solving” the military recruiting crisis.

West Point's Modern War Institute, in conjunction with Training and Doctrine Command, initiated a contest in July 2023 to elicit essays describing a novel approach to "solve the recruiting crisis". Entries were accepted until September 3, 2023. To date, the winning entries have not been announced. The below reproduced short essay was originally written as …

NATO Operations and the Unifying Power of a Common Language

Language is a window to thought. In the Army, we often say that โ€œwords have meaningโ€ and they do. But even more so, the manner in which we crystalize thoughts into language colors the thoughts themselves. The goods somewhat assume the shape of the vessel in which they are carried. Learning a language beyond oneโ€™s …

The Day After Kabul

By Garri Benjamin Hendell Everyone in the American military community watched the (most recent) fall of Kabul with their mouths agape. For a generation who grew up in the shadow of Vietnam, to watch another ignominious American retreat was shocking and painful. This was, presumably, an immeasurably worse experience for those that served and lost …

Forget Love in the Time of Cholera, How About Assessment in the Time of COVID-19?

Assessment is how the military determines โ€œthe overall effectiveness of employing capabilities during military operations.โ€. That said, the military does not practice this dark art well. If an objective is clear-cut, measuring its performance is also straightforward. Broader objectives cause problems. This was the challenge in Iraq. It was also at the heart of the …